Nice camera and pictures, I picked up a Canon G15 for portability and it shoots in Raw. I won't buy a camera that doesn't shoot in Raw. For most pictures I use a Canon 1d Mark IV, it is big & heavy, but it takes nice pix.

If you really want to do a valid test it would have to be at a meet, otherwise there are way too many variables to say which camera takes a better photo. You can have a contest on best photo, just let all the technology be allowed. I don't have a single photo that isn't touched up a bit in Lightroom or PhotoShop.